As digital systems concentrate power and fragment society, Plurality proposes democratic participation and collaboration across differences as a way to steer technology toward shared benefit. Taiwan’s civic experiments show how tools can surface collective knowledge and give people a meaningful role in decisions that affect them. Trust in the Age of Acceleration concurs: build trust through participation, connect people across disciplines, and help institutions evolve alongside technology. Progress means strengthening our capacity to shape the future together.
“If men are to remain civilized, the art of associating together must grow and improve in the same ratio as the quality of conditions is increased.” ~ Alexis De Tocqueville
“Trust those who seek truth, but fear those who’ve found it.”
“Give the public itself the means to enter into the decision making process that will shape their future.”
“Both chaos and top-down order are the are the antitheses of all life, complexity, and beauty in human society and nature.”
“Plurality is thus the third way between Liberalism and Technocracy, much like life is the middle ground between stasis and chaos.”
Chappy’s Review
Plurality is perhaps the most well-aligned book I’ve ever read on The AI Collective and what I believe this community stands for. A great call to arms at the end!
Pro tip: Read online > Audible if you can. the Audible recording is crowdsourced and thus an excruciating listen – perhaps not a great example of diverse open source contribution > centralized markets 😅. Maybe someone can release an ElevenLabs dub?
Key Takeaways
Technocracy seeks a unified rational system; libertarianism starts with the sovereignty of the atomistic individual
The alternative is collaboration across diversity, avoiding both centralized control and the breakdown of the social fabric
Supermodularity: the whole is greater than the sum of its parts; differences in knowledge, skills, values, and perspectives can create gains from collaboration
Build for a range of social groups, not just isolated individuals or a single all-encompassing authority
The historical ambition is augmentation rather than automation: open standards and computing that support democratic participation
Georg Simmel: people become distinct through their particular intersections of groups, especially in complex urban societies
John Dewey: new forms of interdependence create publics that need to recognize themselves and act collectively
Property, identity, and voting should account for social relationships rather than assume self-contained individuals
The book draws on complexity, emergence, and multi-level organization as an alternative to reducing society to a single model
Civic hackers, online deliberation, presidential hackathons, and collaborative responses to misinformation offer practical experiments in digital democracy
Opinion clustering can reveal areas of agreement across otherwise divided groups
The notes also flag high volunteering demands, reduced in-person participation during Covid, a narrow policy focus, and no requirement for government response
Five rights / operating-system properties: 1) Identity + personhood; 2) Association; 3) Commercial trust; 4) Property + contract; 5) Access
Identity should combine plural sources of trust, including social attestation and recovery, while protecting the context in which information is shared
Association depends on common knowledge, common beliefs, and common intentions
Widely shared non-proprietary protocols should support payments, property sharing, and reliable access to information
Data trusts / mediators of individual data let creators act collectively rather than negotiate alone
Federated learning + data federation offer ways to collaborate without pooling everything under one owner
Three rights of property: Usus, the right to use; Abusus, the right to alter or dispose; Fructus, the right to the value it creates
Norms and legal structures often matter more than contracts alone; data sharing needs a stable social understanding
The book explores seven forms: 1) Post-Symbolic Communication; 2) Immersive Shared Reality; 3) Creative Collaborations; 4) Augmented Deliberation; 5) Adaptive Administration; 6) ⿻ Voting; 7) Social Markets
Markets connect many people with relatively shallow interaction; intimate collaboration permits deeper exchange within smaller groups
Post-symbolic communication and immersive shared reality explore richer shared experience through sensory interfaces and virtual environments; these are prospective possibilities, not established outcomes
Preserve and generate diversity rather than prematurely optimize all collaboration around one objective function
Applications extend to workplaces, health, and media, including more inclusive talent allocation, joint production of health, and collaborative journalism
Community Notes compares judgments across the opinion spectrum rather than relying only on aggregate popularity
LLMs and graph methods could help people translate, distill information, and deliberate across larger and more diverse groups
Clear purpose, active inclusion, small-group breakouts, turn-taking, active listening, and good notes still matter; informal dominance can defeat an apparently structureless process
Attention is scarce, so representation remains necessary; deliberation is too slow for some decisions and does not always provide the most transparent or legitimate procedure
AI representatives could act faster than people can follow, creating a new accountability problem
Voting must address two questions: how to measure and weight degrees of interest; how to make representation flexible and adaptive
The book explores correlation discounting, eigenvoting, quadratic liquid democracy, and assisted realtime voting; these are proposed approaches rather than a settled replacement
Administration faces opposing failures: rigid rules discard relevant detail, while complex rules become hard to navigate
Adaptive systems could make administration and credentials more responsive to different contexts
Private exchanges can look efficient in isolation while producing poor collective outcomes
Partial common ownership: owners self-assess an asset's value and must allow purchase at that price, connecting truthful taxation with turnover of monopolized assets
Community currencies and currencies of esteem / accomplishment recognize forms of value that a single financial measure misses
Polycentric commerce connects multiple value / reputation systems rather than relying on a single centralized store of value
The book proposes combining decentralized entrepreneurial ecosystems, human rights + democracy, and public investment that advances societal interests
It calls for public open-source software R&D, with a proposed commitment of 1% of global GDP
Balance distributed autonomy / innovation with shared knowledge / diffusion; blitzscaling and arms races can entrench unequal access
Immediate action includes adopting collaborative tools, explaining the ideas, organizing local experiments, and championing changes within existing institutions
The long-term aim is to upgrade technical infrastructure and institutions through broad participation rather than impose a top-down blueprint
Notes
These are notes from the 2024 published book, but it’s continuously maintained and updated by the community! Continuously updated version:
Internet creates communities but also polarization and surveillance
Democracy is waning
Plurality: democracy + collaborative technology
2: Information Technology and Democracy
2-0: A Widening Gulf
“Laws and institutions must go hand-in-hand with the human mind”
“We might as well require a man to wear the coat which fit him as a boy as a civilized society to remain ever under the regimen of their barbarous ancestors”
↑ focus on complexity, emergence, multi-level organization, multi-level causation
Multi-level game theory
Complex = edge of chaos and order
“Steering towards and widening this narrow corridor”
Gödel + Church un-solvability
Chaos theory
Fractals
Bell’s theorem = superposition
Relativity, quantum physics
Plurality: “the application of an analogous perspective to the understanding of human societies and technologically the attempt to build formal institutions and government systems that account for and resemble these structures”
Technocratic: replace messy bureaucracy with massive unified rational AI system
Libertarian: sovereignty of the atomistic individual
↑ there must be another way
3-2: Connected Society
3 core of modern democracy:
Property, identity, voting
Henry George: taxes and land must be used productively
Eg. who should capture all the land value accrual for the SF Bay Area?
Argues it should be captured plurally, not by any individual
Georg Simmel: pioneered social networks
We’re deeply / fundamentally social
In small isolated groups, tend to define self largely collectively
Individuation occurs largely through affiliation with groups
Cities → many affiliations → not much in common with generalized person
Feeling of unique ↔ isolated
Rather than analyzing starting with the individual, view them as “an emergent property of the complexity and dynamism of modern urban societies”
John Dewey
Trade groups → secrets → shared identity + culture → allows the social circle to act as a collective agent
Govt’s + markets fail due to externalities at large scale
Democratic action can address the failing of markets
We need more “mirrors” - social entrepreneurs
↑ job: perceive + explain the new forms of interdependence + empower this new emergent public to come into existence
Norbert Weiner
Cybernetics: “the science and control of communication in complex systems like the animal and machine”
“The science of communication within and governance of, by, and for networks.”
“Severe critic of capitalism as failing basic principles of cybernetic stabilization and creation of homeostasis and advocate of radically more responsible use and deployment of technology.”
3-3: The Lost Dao
“Every country has been forced by the limits of available IT to homogenize and simplify social institutions in a monist atomist mold that runs into direct conflict with such [democratic] values”
Lick “built and shaped much of what became the field of computer science”
Dave Engelbart PC
ARPANET
Open standards > top-down decision making
Ease of navigation + recombination (packet switching, HTTP, TCP/IP)
Ted Nelson
“Long forgotten” “insecurity, exploitative structure, inhumane features of WWW”
Secure identity systems
Embedded protocols for commerce
Secure information sharing + control
Lick’s 1980 “Computers and Government” manifesto
Two scenarios:
Dominated by monopolistic corporate control
Full societal mobilization to make computing support + serve democracy
Potential social ills:
Pervasive surveillance, public distrust of gov’t
Paralysis of gov’t as falling behind in tech
Debasement of creative professions
Monopolization + corporate exploitation
Pervasive digital misinformation
Siloing of info
Gov’t data inaccurate
Control by private entities of fundamental platforms for speech + public discourse
Wikipedia as shining light of deliberative participatory resource
OSS challenges underlying assumptions of market economies
Crypto
Gov tech, civic tech
Online deliberation
4: Freedom
4-0: Rights, Operating Systems and ⿻ Freedom
Rights are the foundation of democracy
UN UDHR:
Equality, life, liberty, personal security, speech, thought, conscience, property, association, etc.
Many democracies have destroyed themselves by eroding rights
Europe positive definition of rights, US negative (freedom-based)
OSs must constantly adapt, defend integrity
New phenomenon: information is abundant, attention is scarce
Rights x OSs = “interpersonal networking OSs”
Need more specialized INOSs
Hypergraph:
Nodes + communities + levels
5 rights / OS properties:
Identity + personhood
Association
Commercial trust
Property + contract
Access
Need widely shared non-proprietary protocols for payments, sharing property, etc. (crypto?)
4-1: Identity and Personhood
Linkage, graph
Tradeoff: establishment vs protection
Gov’t issued identities do a poor job of protecting identity
SSO providers
Data collection dossiers
Online identities
Fragmented, low interoperability
Potentially pseudonymous
Rich but narrow slice of life
Digital national ID (eg. India)
Biometric (eg. World Coin) not good enough*
Plural methods, eg. friends + family attesting claims
Social forms of recovery for sensitive info
Solving trust thru transitivity
Dunbar’s number
Preserving social context is more important than “privacy” (eg. first kiss fellow lover)
4-2: Association and ⿻ Publics
“If men are to remain civilized, the art of associating together must grow and improve in the same ratio as the quality of conditions is increased” ~ Alexis De Tocqueville
“Collective actions through political parties, civic associations, labor unions, and businesses are always necessary”
Goal: outline a theory of the informational requirements for association
↑ legal basis: contractual arrangements that govern a sharing of assets - real, human, intellectual, financial - in a common undertaking towards a shared purpose
Eg. “the cloud” for digital asset sharing
Focusing here on storage, computation, and data
Not focusing on electromagnetic spectrum, code, names, URLs, NFTs, etc.
Analogies to real world:
Storage = land
Computation = fuel
Data = human inputs / labor + artifacts people use / capital
Time sharing
Many of resources above lay dormant / wasted
Despite physical assets seeming to be more challenging to share on the face of it, we’re far more efficient because society has had more time to experiment, iterate, optimize allocation
Storage:
Filecoin not ubiquitous, not for live data
Top 2 cloud providers capture 2/3 of the market
Lending + pooling of assets is ubiquitous in the economy
3 rights of property:
Usus: right to use
Abusus: right to alter or dispose
Fructus: the right to the value it creates
Norms + legal structures often >> contracts
Thus, need a “stable social understanding” of data sharing
Need more social Darwinian evolution of methods for data sharing
Federated learning + data federation
Data policy needs to be more group > individual - especially since almost all data is social / networked
Datatrusts / mediators of individual data (MIDs): data creators need to act collectively
Eg. unions
Data should become more like property
FCC, ICANN largely defined technoctatically
Eg. search engine is actually better for market than domain squatting
4-5: Access
“We all can and must make our own meanings of life, but we are denied our own equal right to do so if some of us receivemanipulated inputs to the global information commons.”
“Plurality is thus the third way between Liberalism and Technocracy, much like life is the middle ground between stasis and chaos.”
“It is a movement we have perhaps 3-5 years to set in motion”
Ways to get involved, start…
Immediate horizon:
Explain, recommend, tell its stories to friends
Adopt a range of plurality tech tools
Organize movements, agenda
Near-term political reforms
Steer personal diet of tech use
Employees can champion within orgs
Academics can study “”
Cultural leaders, artists, journalists, and other communicators can tell the stories of the movement
Intermediate horizons:
Reinvent institutions to include more diversity, plurality
Join political movements
Hackathons + ideathons for local problems
Political platforms + parties
Increasingly organized political movements
Regulators, employees, business leaders, academics, media + creatives practicing plurality*
Transformative horizons:
“Fundamental rewriting of a range of technical infrastructures, social relationships, and organizational institutions.”
“Thus culture, politics, activism, business, technology, and research can all form a mutually reinforcing virtuous cycle.”
There can be no top-down
Everyone can / should get involved*
Goal is 1B people “know about it or are sympathetic to its aims” by 2030
“Connect, affiliate, rally, mobilize, and join us in the deliberate and committed movement to build a more deliberate and harmonious world. Let us free the future together.”